Current Position:Home > Duo Core 2 & Windows XP HOME (S2)

Duo Core 2 & Windows XP HOME (S2)

Update:10-11Source: network consolidation
Advertisement
I just purchased an iMac 20" Duo Core 2. Being that I'm NOT an experienced Mac user, I had the CompUSA service tech install Windows for me. He told me that I couldn't install Windows XP HOME (S2) - that I had to install Windows XP Pro (S2) because of the new Duo Core 2 processor. XP Pro cost an extra $100.
Does anyone know how accurate this is? The current version of Boot Camp (1.1.1) states that XP HOME (S2) can be used.
If I had been better informed, I could have bought the 24" iMac with the money the Techs weasled me out of with their bad information and bad install of the XP system. I had to reinstall XP when I got home.
Thanks for your replies.

The Best Answer

Advertisement
I've seen a few people stuble into this confusing area before, it is interesting to see that Microsoft isn't making things any clearer on their web page. Unfortuneatly mhunter was off base. As you can see on this page,
http://www.microsoft.com/licensing/highlights/multicore.mspx
Microsoft differentiates a processor from a core pretty clearly. At the bottom of the page it even mentions that while the per processor licensing (a server thing) doesn't apply to XP Pro, or XP Home the following applies...
"A. Microsoft Windows XP Professional and Microsoft Windows XP Home are not affected by this policy as they are licensed per installation and not per processor. Windows XP Professional can support up to two processors regardless of the number of cores on the processor. Microsoft Windows XP Home supports one processor."
A better description of this policy, and the product hardware limitations that are put in place can be found in the following Microsoft technical briefing paper.
http://download.microsoft.com/download/f/1/e/f1ecd771-cf97-4d98-9a1b-b86e3f24e08 f/multicorehyperthreadbrief.doc
In which it clearly states,
Software Do technically enforced processor limits
support multicore and hyperthreaded processors?
Windows XP Home Edition Yes
Windows XP Media Center Edition Yes
Windows XP Professional Yes
This microsoft BLOG page summarizes what I have outlined here.
http://blogs.msdn.com/oldnewthing/archive/2006/10/02/780255.aspx
The bottom line it, XP Home DOES support multiple cores on a single processor. If you have multiple processors, You'll need XP Pro regardless of how many cores they have.
More proof of this can be seen here.
http://searchwincomputing.techtarget.com/tip/0,289483,sid68_gci1189223,00.html
From this link you can see that XP Home does indeed install the Hardware Abstraction Layer (HAL) to support multple cores on a single processor (like the Intel iMacs). If you had a MacPro, XP Pro would be your only choice.
It's interesting to me that this issue is still so unclear since the PC world addressed it some time back.
Dual G4, Powerbook G4, Intel iMac, Dual 2.5G5, Xserves and more   Mac OS X (10.4.8)  
  • Duo Core 2 & Windows XP HOME (S2) Update:10-11

    I just purchased an iMac 20" Duo Core 2. Being that I'm NOT an experienced Mac user, I had the CompUSA service tech install Windows for me. He told me that I couldn't install Windows XP HOME (S2) - that I had to install Windows XP Pro (S2) because of

  • Sharing hard drive with windows xp on imac intel duo core Update:11-30

    Hi, I was wondering whether I could give over anymore of the hard disk on my imac intel duo core to Windows xp? If so, how would I go about doing that? Thanks in advanceAt this point I think that you would need to use Boot Camp to remove the current

  • Can not for the life of me get printing to work on my mac mini duo core Update:10-11

    I have a photosmart 7550 and laserjet 1012. And I can't get my mac mini to recognize either printer. This has been driving me nuts. I was a long time mac user in the 80s and early 90s. Switched to Windows. Just switched back with the mac mini (intel

  • Mighty Mouse problem with duo core intel mac mini & 26" LCD/TV display Update:10-11

    I have an Olevia 26" LCD/TV display connected to my Intel Duo core mac mini and I have been using a Mighty Mouse with it from the start but all of a sudden the mouse pointer will not come out of the upper right corner. It moves out a little and then

  • Images appear then disappear in mail on 10.4.4 intel duo core mac Update:10-11

    In mail, running 10.4.4 on my new duo core intel mac, i am getting images in mails beautifully - and then for no explicable reason they disappeare and revert to code - and nothing i do will bring them back - i have already checked the box for downloa

  • Importing FCE to FCP and G5 iMac to Duo Core iMac issues Update:11-30

    I mainly film & edit weddings, but work on a number of other things as well. Someone told me to try hitting escape when I get the error message window, which worked good enough on a few of the projects, but not on most. Have been using FCP 5.1.4 for

  • Set Duo core to single? Update:11-30

    I require the ability to run with a single core due to a certain conflict with Duo Core running and need some help on how to do this...if possible. MoBo=P6NGM2-L Bios v2.2 CPU:Intel Pentium Dual Core E5200 Processor BX80571E5200 - 2.50GHz, 2MB Cache,

  • I have a 2006 model macbook duo core with 10.4.11, can I somehow upgrade to lion? Update:11-30

    My 2006 Duo Core Macbook has OS X 10.4.11.  Can I upgrade this computer to Lion or do I need to buy a new one?  Computer is in great shape and would like to keep it.  Any info would be awesome.  Thanks! DaveIf it's a Core Duo model than you can upgra

  • Sleep problem with iMac Duo Core Update:11-30

    I purchased this 20" iMac Duo Core five days ago. Whenever the iMac enter sleep mode with pulsating indicator light below the screen, waking up the iMac always cause complete reboot of iMac. Is this a known issue with 20" iMac Core Duo or there

  • Alternative OSes on 975X w/ Duo Core 2 6600? Update:11-30

    Hello.  After six years I'm finally replacing my PIII with a new build using the MSI 975X and Intel Duo Core 2 6600.  My current system dual-boots Windows 98SE, Linux, BeOS, QNX, Oberon, and FreeBSD.  Does anyone have experience installing and bootin