Current Position:Home > BSP or Java ?

BSP or Java ?

Update:11-30Source: network consolidation
Advertisement
Hi
I have a basic question but I am facing it today so would like to know from SAP folks about it.
Given a task of developing web applications out of SAP back end (R/3 or BW) which route do I follow
1) BSP - Develop the front end in BSP (HTMLB). The data retrieval from back end SAP system will be easier as BSP development is integrated into SE80.
2) Develop Front end in JAVA and use JCO/JCA/XMLA to connect to back end SAP system to retrive the data ...
WHich one is better in terms of
1) Development
2) Future (considering SAP's migration towards Java tools)
3) Support
Thanks

The Best Answer

Advertisement
hi,
huuuum, Well BSP or Java ??
I would say, if some one has gone through the Craig Cmehil, first three or four weblogs, he/she will get his answer, more over one has to select BSP or Java on basis of resources avaiable !
for example if you dont have SAP WAS application server or your house is lack with ABAP OO skills, than ofcource the choice left is Java/JCO solution, which certainly has some problems, a few of them listed here
In JCo performance will always be a bottel neck
Ofcourse all functionality of SAP is not avaiable through RFC enable BAPIs ( though there are more then  thousand BAPIs avaiable, but still not all functionality of SAP)
Many Experts who have hand on experience on both platforms says that, WAS/BSP is much more faster, stable, robuts and reliable in comparision to J2EE/JSP. you might can consider to read the following artical
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/servlet/prt/portal/prtroot/com.sap.km.cm.docs/documents/a1-8-4/clash of the titans iii.pdf
Hope it helps,
Regards,
Haider Syed
  • BSP or Java ? Update:11-30

    Hi I have a basic question but I am facing it today so would like to know from SAP folks about it. Given a task of developing web applications out of SAP back end (R/3 or BW) which route do I follow 1) BSP - Develop the front end in BSP (HTMLB). The

  • PCUI/BSP  vs JAVA iviews? Update:11-30

    Hi    I installed business package for crm and i am planning to develop some new iviews. Rightnow I am confused to decide on whether to develop the iviews in java or in PCUI/BSP? could some one please let me know what is the criteria to decide which

  • Your opinion on:  BSP or Java Webdynpro or ABAP Webdynpro? Update:11-30

    Could you please give me your opinion on the business scenario we have here: We are implementing SRM 4.0 with backend R/3 4.6C, WAS 6.4 and Portal 6.0. SRM has its typical shopping cart applications mainly for procurement and the workflow trail displ

  • BSP, Webdynpro, Java - Pros / Cons Update:11-30

    In the past I made programs using BSP and ABAP. I read a lot of webdynpros and know about the advantages comparing to BSP. But are there also disadvantes? And what's about the Java technology? I read a lot about the Java technology using SAP. But now

  • Captcha on BSP using java is possible? Java allowed in BSP? Update:11-30

    Hello to all, My client ask for a captcha on a BSP page of autoregister of SRM module. I have found the posts using PHP [https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/4e539c30-0501-0010-3291-a4c4193a6414|https://www.sdn.sap.com/

  • BSP vs Web Dynpro ABAP Update:11-30

    Hello, we are looking for a listing that states the functional and technical differences between Web Dynpro ABAP an BSP. Is there anybody who has come along such a list ? Tx a lot in advance! Best regards, AnaAnnette, check this The SAP Web Applicati

  • BSP Date Validation Update:11-30

    Hi Experts, How to validate two dates in BSP through Java Script. I want date comparison code through java script that can check wether date 2 is smaller than date 1. All points will be rewarded to correct and quick answers.Here is the code... functi

  • Decoding in BSP Update:11-30

    Hi I am passing a encoding parameter into BSP using java.net.URLencoder class. How to decode the parameter in BSP which is encoded in java using java encoder class. Regards, puneet aggarwalI am using the code as l_fname = request->get_form_field( nam

  • Adobe Interactive forms for material creation Update:11-30

    Hi, We are considering Adobe interactive forms application to create and change materials in our R/3 system (4.7, WAS 6.20). I understand that there are already standard forms available from Adobe for this. I would like to know whether anyone has use

  • CRM Upgrade Update:11-30

    Hi, We will be starting our work on a CRM upgrade from 520 to 600 soon. CRM is linked to R3 as backend. The client does not have too many custom objects at the moment, which is good :). There is limited interaction between EP and CRM. At the moment I